POSFriends

This is the only category? => Dungins and Durgins => Topic started by: Namine on November 25, 2012, 01:04:26 AM

Title: Mafia Game Over Mafia Wins
Post by: Namine on November 25, 2012, 01:04:26 AM
Gameplay Log:

1. Soaprman - Godfather
2. Scrow Funk - Thief
3. KennyMan666 Bus Driver (Town Aligned) (Died Night 0)
4. Gamma_Metroid Town (Lynched Day 1)
5. Draino Mafia (Lynched Day 2)
6. Spat Town
7. SK Mafia
8. Kejardon Detective (died night 2)


Night 0: Kenny dieded. He was the bus driver.
Day 1: Gamma_Metroid lynched. He was a normal town dude.
Night 1: Nothing happened.
Day 2: Draino Lynched He was a mafia.
Night 2: Kej murdered
Day 2: Mafia declared winner.
=====================================================================

The POS Friends are sleeping now, but something is lurking in the shadows.
Title: Re: Mafia Day 1
Post by: Namine on November 25, 2012, 02:47:49 PM
POS Town, a nice quiet little town that didn't have much going on. People being people, going around doing their business. I was a detective, wasn't much going on crime wise. A few petty thefts here and there, nothing that really needed a detective. However the pay was good so I didn't say no.

I heard a gunshot that woke me abruptly from a restless night. I knew something was going to go down, but I didn't realize how right I was going to be. The dame rushed in, she was a beauty that dame or was it a man. I couldn't tell really.

"Come quick! Someone's been murdered."

So I put on my tench coat and headed out. There was a large body laying in front of Spat's house. He was the local Pimpmaster: Flex, but Spat oddly stood above the body looking at it.

"I didn't do it, he just dropped dead!"

It was Kennymann666, laying in the pool of his own blood with the keys to the Bus.

Whoever did this, sure wasn't playing around. No clues anywhere. This was something most unusual in these cases. I looked around, any one of these people could've done it.

But who?

================================


TLDNR: Kennyman666 was killed. Bus Driver by the mafia. 


(Also had to remove  starvingcrazily for not confirming role in time sorry, next time fo sure!)

You have until Thursday 11/29 midnight Eastern Time, I believe that's a little over 72 hours.

(Also for story purposes: The narrator is me acting as a detective, this does not mean there's definitely a detective here in game. In case there's any confusion.)
Title: Re: Mafia Day 1
Post by: Kejardon on November 25, 2012, 03:51:33 PM
Well, I didn't do it, so which one of you did? You might as well fess up now.
Title: Re: Mafia Day 1
Post by: Draino on November 25, 2012, 04:07:17 PM
Namine: Can we change our vote after it's cast? I'm planning on the usual first day abstention but I don't want to cast a vote  and then have the detective come forward or something.
Title: Re: Mafia Day 1
Post by: Namine on November 25, 2012, 06:16:14 PM
Vote changing is highly encouraged as is finger pointing arguing and betrayals.  :thumbsup:
Title: Re: Mafia Day 1
Post by: Gamma_Metroid on November 25, 2012, 06:53:04 PM
An abstain is usually the best way to go day 1, so unless anyone has a better idea:

[vote] abstain

I'm guessing
Whoever did this, sure wasn't playing around. No clues anywhere. This was something most unusual in these cases. I looked around, any one of these people could've done it.
means that there is actually no clue left tonight, and isn't just for flavor.

What is the usual mafia:town ratio?  I think there are probably two in this game, but if SV was part of the ratio, is 3 out of the question?
Title: Re: Mafia Day 1
Post by: Namine on November 25, 2012, 08:43:33 PM
No clues at all this time I think I stated that in the discussion thread.
Title: Re: Mafia Day 1
Post by: KarmaPolice on November 26, 2012, 12:02:53 AM
Well, then we have no information.

[vote] Yoshi348
Title: Re: Mafia Day 1
Post by: Draino on November 26, 2012, 03:44:52 AM
ugh, playing mafia like a rational person is so boring. but I guess it is the best thing to do day 1.

[VOTE] abstain
Title: Re: Mafia Day 1
Post by: SK on November 26, 2012, 06:55:14 PM
i have lots of enlightening details to add to this conversation

[vote] abstain
Title: Re: Mafia Day 1
Post by: Kejardon on November 26, 2012, 08:41:57 PM
Come on you people, abstaining is not how the town wins  :erectiledysfunction:
Title: Re: Mafia Day 1
Post by: KarmaPolice on November 26, 2012, 11:56:58 PM
We have to have information to do anything.
Title: Re: Mafia Day 1
Post by: Soaprman on November 27, 2012, 06:30:36 PM
HEy Guys Visit My Website At WWW.NotMafia.Com For The Latest On Not Being Mafia
Title: Re: Mafia Day 1
Post by: Kejardon on November 28, 2012, 04:09:26 AM
Guys I'm pretty certain Abstain didn't kill KennyMan666.
[vote] Gamma_Metroid
Title: Re: Mafia Day 1
Post by: Namine on November 28, 2012, 11:52:39 AM
Votes:

Gamma_Metroid: 1

Less than 13 hours remain.
Title: Re: Mafia Day 1
Post by: Draino on November 28, 2012, 03:30:58 PM
you know what, you're right. changing my vote.

[VOTE] Gamma
Title: Re: Mafia Day 1
Post by: Gamma_Metroid on November 28, 2012, 04:27:34 PM
uhh
Title: Re: Mafia Day 1
Post by: Scrow Funk on November 28, 2012, 04:37:48 PM
uhh

(http://i80.photobucket.com/albums/j191/Son_07/Phoenix%20Wright/Guilty.gif)

[vote] gamma
Title: Re: Mafia Day 1
Post by: Gamma_Metroid on November 28, 2012, 06:31:18 PM
no seriously what even is this

I'm not mafia and I don't see any reason you'd think otherwise....
Title: Re: Mafia Day 1
Post by: Soaprman on November 28, 2012, 06:34:39 PM
Guys I'm pretty certain Abstain didn't kill KennyMan666.
[vote] Gamma_Metroid

I'm detective and yes he did. I'm willing to forgive him just this once though and not vote for him.
Title: Re: Mafia Day 1
Post by: Gamma_Metroid on November 28, 2012, 07:20:46 PM
:cranky:
Title: Re: Mafia Day 1
Post by: Namine on November 28, 2012, 09:53:05 PM
3 Votes Gamma

2 hours 15 Minutes remain.
Title: Re: Mafia Day 1
Post by: Scrow Funk on November 28, 2012, 10:42:35 PM
1) what happens in the event of a tie

2) what happens if number of abstains = number of votes for [person]
Title: Re: Mafia Day 1
Post by: Namine on November 28, 2012, 11:03:21 PM
Ties = nothing happens. No lynch.

Abstains don't count as actual votes, so essentially whoever has the most votes will be lynched.
Title: Re: Mafia Day 1
Post by: Namine on November 29, 2012, 03:00:17 AM
The town crowded around the body not knowing what to do. The town was crying for blood. A few of them pinned the blame on Gamma Metroid. He didn't look particularly suspicious, but before I could chime in it was too late. The dame grabbed him and gutted his throat.

Someone was sure feeling good because his wallet opened and it was empty. A mafia member wouldn't have an empty wallet, he was just a run of the mill banker. A simple townsperson just trying to make an honest living.

Night was coming. I told the citizens to just go back to their homes and keep them locked tight. I had a feeling this wouldn't be an isolated incident...


========================

Gamma_Metroid was lynched. He was just a townie.

 :wow: Good jorb guys!

Night 1 begins! You have 72 hours. (3 days)
Title: Re: Mafia Day 2
Post by: Namine on December 02, 2012, 02:38:16 AM
I woke up late today feeling uneasy. No sounds of a scream, nothing. I walked outside and the townspeople were having a meeting about the other day. Two people had been killed, one murdered and one innocently lynched. Maybe the ones behind the murders were giving up? No I doubt that, I had to keep on going, there had to be a clue somewhere, but where?

========================================

Day 2 log: No one was killed today.

72 Hours (Well 73 since I updated early)
Title: Re: Mafia Day 2
Post by: KarmaPolice on December 02, 2012, 03:32:24 AM
Ladies and gentleman, I have information :
I'm not mafia
Title: Re: Mafia Day 2
Post by: Soaprman on December 02, 2012, 10:30:14 AM
Ladies and gentleman, I have information :
I'm not mafia

knew it

fucking knew it
Title: Re: Mafia Day 2
Post by: Kejardon on December 02, 2012, 06:05:40 PM
This makes me just want to metagame now.  :erectiledysfunction: I'm gonna try to avoid doing that though and hope that maybe, just maybe we can get some discussion and actual mafiaing stuff going on.

And to start, I'm going to go ahead and roleclaim, since my role is so OP it doesn't matter if I claim or not. I am the Detective. Once per game, I can detect a person during night and Namine will tell me they're a townie.
N0 I didn't use it and relied on instinct instead for D1 lynch. Unfortunately my Mafia instinct sucks :thumbsdown:. Last night I detected Spat and got Townie, which makes me definitely want to lynch him, since that's what Godfathers and Thieves both detect as.

This is why I told the mafia they might as well fess up day 1. You cannot escape the blind one-shot Detective  :(9):
Title: Re: Mafia Day 2
Post by: Jack on December 02, 2012, 06:30:52 PM
It was me, I did it. I killed everyone, what'chu gonna do about it  :cranky:
Title: Re: Mafia Day 2
Post by: Soaprman on December 02, 2012, 07:53:16 PM
Kej: by "didn't use it" do you mean you picked Gamma at random anyway despite your night 0 detect or do you mean that you submitted no action night 0?

Jack: don't post in the gameplay threads to games you aren't playing, please. (Not sure if you knew that, but now you do)
Title: Re: Mafia Day 2
Post by: Draino on December 02, 2012, 08:43:37 PM
I am the real detective and  :urmrgay:

It's a nice lie you got there- you're even claiming one-shot, to make it seem plausible. Unfortunately that detail is not plausible at all. What kind of mafia game would have a detective who could only detect once in the entire game (which is what he is saying, Soap)? That would be a huge design imbalance- it would give the townies way too little information and would make the mafia insanely powerful. There is no way that would happen.

Here's what really happened: I can detect once per night (as usual). Night 0 I detected Soap, who is a townie. Night 1 I was curious about you, Kej, since you started the bandwagon on a townie yesterday. You also came up townie. Now, regular old townies don't claim detective (unless they are me that one time), so I posit that
ur
mr
godfather.

[VOTE] Kejardon
Title: Re: Mafia Day 2
Post by: Scrow Funk on December 02, 2012, 09:03:37 PM
sorry m8, i have to side with kejardon on this one

[vote] draino
Title: Re: Mafia Day 2
Post by: KarmaPolice on December 02, 2012, 09:19:51 PM
I'm the townie, way to detect, Kejardon! However, I'll hold off on voting a while to get a better feel for what's happening.
Title: Re: Mafia Day 2
Post by: Soaprman on December 02, 2012, 09:41:50 PM
One-shot detective does seem pretty weak unless there are some other power roles hanging around. I'd like to hear Kejjo's follow-up on this one.
Title: Re: Mafia Day 2
Post by: Kejardon on December 02, 2012, 10:00:37 PM
What kind of mafia game would have a detective who could only detect once in the entire game (which is what he is saying, Soap)? That would be a huge design imbalance- it would give the townies way too little information and would make the mafia insanely powerful. There is no way that would happen.

I recall a game where there was 2.5 mafia in a 6 player game.
I'm not saying it's balanced in the slightest, I've been poking fun at my role the whole time! Either way, the complete lack of information is why I've been aggressive because, unless there is a second detective or something (I've been somewhat entertaining the idea that there were no real normal townies, just a bunch of one-shot detectives, but that's looking less likely now), I know the townies are kinda info-screwed and lynching, even randomly, is towns best bet.

Anyways, my own view, there are two options here:
Draino is being honest
- There is maybe ONE person that detects as anything other than townie, the normal mafia I assume there is but isn't listed in the roles.
- Soap, Spat, Me, and Draino are clear (unless Kenny busdrove Soap), so the normal mafia must be SCrow or SK
Draino is lieing
- Most likely motivation is mafia hoping to get 5 tonight then 4 tomorrow for a 2-mafia win
- Brings up the question of Namine info-screwing town

Soap:
I had one use, didn't want to blow it N0 with no hunches to follow, so I tried to stir stuff up D1 (I couldn't think of any reason not to) and figure out a maybe useful detect for N1.

Gonna hold off on voting for a while. Considering we have 6 people alive I half think an abstain is best on the chance we can get some more solid information.
For whatever it's worth though, if I had to pick my gut is saying lynch Draino.
Title: Re: Mafia Day 2
Post by: Draino on December 02, 2012, 10:52:40 PM
The only "more solid information" that could possibly come up is who the doctor protected, and that's not going to find us a mafia member. (also it would get him killed. stay safe today, doctor!) Or if Kej is actually a regular townie trying to make the game more fun. Which I understand totally because I have done it before. Kej, if you are one then I will withdraw my vote. Better that the doc only have one detective to protect.

For what it's worth I don't think Namine would screw over the town with a gimmicky game, since this was supposed to be a straight game of mafia. I already know the detective role isn't one-shot. We may not absolutely need to lynch today but if we can get a probable godfather, then I say we should go for it.
Title: Re: Mafia Day 2
Post by: Kejardon on December 02, 2012, 11:01:55 PM
The only "more solid information" that could possibly come up is who the doctor protected, and that's not going to find us a mafia member...
Oh.
Ok then.
[vote] Draino
Title: Re: Mafia Day 2
Post by: Namine on December 03, 2012, 04:22:56 AM
Draino - 2

Kejardon - 1

23 Hours Remain
Title: Re: Mafia Day 2
Post by: Draino on December 03, 2012, 08:49:08 PM
this is why democracy doesn't work.
Title: Re: Mafia Day 2
Post by: Namine on December 04, 2012, 02:14:32 AM
The town was yelling at Kejardon. He claimed he knew Spat was just a townie, but Draino wasn't having it.

"I'm the real detective!" Draino said, "I think I have to call bullshit on this."

No one was having it, the boy's goose was cooked. The town screamed for justice. I didn't see why, no one had been killed that night. However the town had spoken. As I was about to take him in for questioning the pulled a gun out.

"You won't take me alive copper!" Then blam. He shot himself in the head. His brains were plastered everywhere on Spat's house of Sports baseball card shop. A little card came out. He was one of them. Satisfied I watched as the police cleaned up the chunks of Draino from the street. Night was coming, the godfather was going to strike back with all his fury. I just knew it.


=======================================

Draino was Mafia and you killed him.

 :spot:

Night 2 has begun. You have 73 hours. December 7: 3AM EST.
Title: Re: Mafia Night 2
Post by: KarmaPolice on December 04, 2012, 04:10:39 AM
I need my compensation, yo. I got BRAINS in my shit.
Title: Re: Mafia Night 2
Post by: Namine on December 07, 2012, 03:32:22 AM
Gunfire woke the citizens up from their sleep last night. I knew what I'd find when I went out there, I was sure of it. Sure enough everyone was crowded around another pool of blood. It seems this time it was my partner, the undercover Detective Kejardon, gunned down while holding a copy of Super Metroid. Damn it I always told him he should be more careful.

"Well shit," SK said as he shot me down, "That sure was easy."

Crawling for my life I looked as Soaprman revealed himself.

"Ha ha ha you lose. Now I shall spread goatse allover this town."

The end
==========================

The game's over since here's what would wind up happening

SK
Soap
Spat
Scrow are left

The Thief could block the actions of someone once during the game. Now it has a little kick where while initially it's a mafia aligned role, but if he blocked a mafia action he'd be aligned to town. I added that to kind of try and balance the game a bit, I don't know how well it worked because Scrow never used his power.

So in essence there's SK, Soap, Scrow as mafia. Spat as town.

Now there was a possibility that scrow could've voted with spat to tie the vote, but then that'd only still ensure a win for Soap. He'd get blocked, another tie would happen then eventually soap would kill either Spat or Scrow and win the game.

I think ending it now is a good idea. Mafia wins!
Title: Re: Mafia Game Over Mafia Wins
Post by: KarmaPolice on December 07, 2012, 03:44:52 AM
3.5 in 8? That is the definition of overpowered...
Title: Re: Mafia Game Over Mafia Wins
Post by: SK on December 07, 2012, 07:05:44 AM
holy shit half of the players in the game were mafia

whaddafuck
Title: Re: Mafia Game Over Mafia Wins
Post by: Soaprman on December 07, 2012, 08:44:27 AM
2.5 would be the MOST I would put in an 8-player game. Mafia ratio should always be between 1/4 and 1/3 of the players. We were thinking amongst ourselves that 3 was overkill. We had no idea there was also a .5 on top of that.

I had neglected to send in an action for us on night 1 and we still mopped shit up. That wasn't much of a game. :(
Title: Re: Mafia Game Over Mafia Wins
Post by: Namine on December 07, 2012, 11:45:58 AM
Technically it was supposed to be 3.5/9 but SV didn't respond. I figured it was too late to change roles at the time. Probably bad judgement on my part.

Oh well this was more of an experiment than anything, didn't really play out like I had wanted (except with Kej and Draino going back and forth that was pretty awesome). Oh well lesson learned.
Title: Re: Mafia Game Over Mafia Wins
Post by: Scrow Funk on December 07, 2012, 02:30:03 PM
i thought i was neutral and planned on helping the town, that's why i voted against draino :guh-huh: :biggoof :wackydeli:
Title: Re: Mafia Day 2
Post by: Kejardon on December 07, 2012, 03:03:33 PM
I recall a game where there was 2.5 mafia in a 6 player game.
I'm not saying it's balanced in the slightest
So how much was the mafia laughing when I said this.

Also didn't Mafia have majority on DAY 2?

Also also you have Day 3 marked as Day 2
Title: Re: Mafia Game Over Mafia Wins
Post by: Namine on December 07, 2012, 03:24:34 PM
i thought i was neutral and planned on helping the town, that's why i voted against draino :guh-huh: :biggoof :wackydeli:

Pretty sure I told you mafia unless you helped a town which would've happened purely by accident since you didn't know who's on what side. :/ I thought that's how the thief role always went down. This is why I don't host many mafia games :/.

I always screw something up, but w/e. Hopefully whoever hosts the next game will do a better job.
Title: Re: Mafia Game Over Mafia Wins
Post by: Scrow Funk on December 07, 2012, 03:53:14 PM
Neutral

Thief: Can Block one night action. Then turns into a mafia(if they block a townie) or a townie (If they blocked a mafia kill). They don't get to know who's mafia or town aligned, and mafia does not know who the thief is. The thief will come up as town if detected.
Title: Re: Mafia Game Over Mafia Wins
Post by: Soaprman on December 07, 2012, 03:54:13 PM
So, the burning question: was the one-shot detective real? The claim made for some decent discussion in the mafia war room. Not too much, though; we knew the game was way in our favor. :P

And yeah, Namine, when SV didn't confirm you should have re-rolled all the roles and sent new PMs out. It's an inconvenience but it's for the good of the game. Of course, thinking 3.5/9 mafia was a good ratio was bad judgement on its own. I get the feeling you just haven't played/hosted many mafia games. Nobody tries a ratio like that unless they're experimenting with an unusual setup.
Title: Re: Mafia Game Over Mafia Wins
Post by: SK on December 07, 2012, 04:02:04 PM
Also didn't Mafia have majority on DAY 2?

whats funny is, even if thief scrow was actually townie aligned, we still tied the votes on day 2. the only reason draino got lynched was because neither me and soap were around/paying attention, otherwise we would have just jump on someone random to at least tie the vote if not just nab another random townie.

it certainly helps that gamma got lynched for no reason other than i think people didnt know about abstaining not meaning anything.

And yeah, Namine, when SV didn't confirm you should have re-rolled all the roles and sent new PMs out.

also this totally. i was pretty concerned when you threw out SV but kept the same roles, because provided the first shot goes well, the mafia already has two townie members down. I think the only way that would have been acceptable is if SV was actually a mafia aligned member, but even then your numbers are pretty one-sided. (well, maybe 2.5 out of 8 would be acceptable, im not sure)
Title: Re: Mafia Game Over Mafia Wins
Post by: Kejardon on December 07, 2012, 04:05:15 PM
One-shot detective was totally real. We also didn't have a doctor.
Title: Re: Mafia Game Over Mafia Wins
Post by: SK on December 07, 2012, 04:06:37 PM
One-shot detective was totally real. We also didn't have a doctor.

namine what the christ
Title: Re: Mafia Game Over Mafia Wins
Post by: Scrow Funk on December 07, 2012, 04:08:12 PM
mods please give namine this avatar in accordance with guidelines posted in the trolling thread (http://i.imgur.com/aZRJl.jpg)
Title: Re: Mafia Game Over Mafia Wins
Post by: KarmaPolice on December 07, 2012, 05:33:01 PM
I still had fun as it happened and it is funny to look back now!
Title: Re: Mafia Game Over Mafia Wins
Post by: Namine on December 07, 2012, 07:43:07 PM
Was trying to make the game interesting and last a little longer.
Title: Re: Mafia Game Over Mafia Wins
Post by: Draino on December 07, 2012, 09:01:43 PM
I think me getting lynched despite being part of a majority was pretty funny. That's the sort of thing would never happen in IRC mafia.

also I've got all of you people disbelieving my fakeclaims. watch me make a real one next game :pacman2: